• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to Carniceria Guanajuato

Located at 1269 Oliver Ave in Indianapolis, Carniceria Guanajuato is a hidden gem that offers both a grocery store and a restaurant. With a reputation for authentic and affordable Mexican cuisine, this spot stands out for its delicious tacos, especially the Al pastor variety. The spacious and eclectic atmosphere adds to the dining experience, while the generous portions and friendly service make it a must-visit for families and foodies alike. Don't miss out on the meat platters and special weekend stews like menudo and pozole for a truly satisfying meal that captures the essence of Mexican flavors.

Carniceria Guanajuato: Reviews & Ratings

Lorenzo M.
Lorenzo M.

I was fully expecting a small hole in the wall restaurant, however I was pleasantly surprised to see a spacious and beautiful restaurant. We came specifically to try the tacos as they've created the reputation of being very inexpensive and authentic tacos. They don't have prices on the menu however I believe they were 2-3 dollars per taco however they tasted like they were 10 dollars each. The service was amazing and our tacos came out within 5 minutes. The fish tacos had great potential however the only flaw was that they were very dry. The Al pastor tacos were a nice change to the fish tacos as they were more savory and juicy. The meat was fantastic and it really nailed the salty-sweet combination. The quality is there and it really puts bang for your buck to another level. The server even gave us a free to go cup of salsa and bag of chips which was incredibly generous.

Kyle S.
Kyle S.

Half restaurant, half grocery store. Impeccable service. There's this cool statue that is right when you walk in. Standard Mexican grub that's always really good. If you want a lot of food do the Surf and Turf. Last time I did Cubano torta...ridiculously big and really good. A solid member of my monthly work lunch rotation.

Scott S.
Scott S.

Great hidden gem! Large portions with authentic Mexican food at very affordable prices. Visit the attached grocery store and the vast meat department for some additional opportunities to take something home. Menu in Spanish and English.

Peter P.
Peter P.

If you are in downtown Indy and are looking for the best Mexican restaurant, look no further. It's not quite walking distance from downtown, but if you have access to a vehicle, it's only 5 minutes away. The restaurant is fairly new and connected to the grocery store. (The grocery store used to have a taqueria inside, but it got so popular that they bought the space next door and opened a full service restaurant. There is still a little taqueria in the grocery store, but the menu is extremely limited now.)

Joe S.
Joe S.

Great Mexican grocery store they have a variety of stuff. It's a pretty big store though not as big as the one in Lafayette Rd. Customer service was great and place was clean and neat as will. Moreover if you're coming for some meat/chicken be sure to come early because the line will be extremely long. I think I waited for like 20-30 minutes to be helped. Also you do have to get a number because they go by number. Furthermore I really recommend this grocery store.

Pam H.
Pam H.

After spending the day downtown watching the state high school soccer games, we felt like trying something new for dinner. Our friends suggested this restaurant and it was only a few minutes from IUPUI, so off we went. You enter the building through the grocery store, which we loved! In fact, my son and his buddy loaded up on Mexican candy after dinner! The restaurant had a interesting, very eclectic atmosphere. For sure unique. The menu was a fun mix of Spanish and English but we were able to figure it out with our limited high school Spanish! The street tacos were excellent- our party tried a bunch and we all decided the chicken was the best. The guacamole was smooth and the small was a big serving! We tried cactus and hot roasted peppers (because why not?), and enjoyed the sides of rice and beans too. The corn tortillas were my favorite part - perfectly cooked. No margaritas, but a cold diet coke waa still a good companion to the spicy hot sauces we added to our meal. Overall a solid choice - I wouldn't drive across town to visit, but if I was nearby I'd be happy to return.

Adriana G.
Adriana G.

We found a very tasty restaurant inside the grocery store. we were pleasantly surprised with the food & the stuff was friendly too. HOWEVER they don't sell alcoholic drinks . Anyways We had the meat table for 4 which was about 33 dollars but it was enough for our family of 6 and still had left overs. We will definitely be having this again when we visit downtown Indy. The grocery store has a great variety of Latin American products. We really like this place in general.

Katherine C.
Katherine C.

This is a great spot for authentic Mexican food. I think it has changed from the hole-in-the-wall with super cheap food that I read about in previous reviews- tacos are now ~$3 with the trade-up being a really lovely ambience with mural paintings and sculptures. Chorizo taco- really delicious, sinful-tasting taco chock full of ground chorizo Carnitas enchiladas- I'm torn on the carnitas. I think they were a li ttle too authentic for me, having quite a bit of skin and kidney (!) pieces. If you are ok with the texture of organ meats, the flavor was still fantastic! As for the grocery side- lots of unique fresh produce and a diverse meat and cheese selection. I really liked the queso oaxaca ("Mexican string cheese"). If you want anything from the butcher or cheese sections, make sure you grab a number! We waited for several minutes before we figured that out.

Jorge Alberto P.
Jorge Alberto P.

Pretty much the best reference for a Mexican restaurant in town! If I'm not wrong this was the first Carnicería Guanajuato in town and not so long ago they did some remodeling to the building next to them and now is a grocery store plus a restaurant! This restaurant has several tables so it can hold a group easily. This time I tried their fish ceviche tostadas and they were not disappointing; most Mexican restaurants add a lot of onion to their ceviche to make it a profit bi giving less fish but not in here. One of their specialties is the steak or mix platter which is a big plate with different types of meat with beans and tortillas which serves up to 6 people. I big recommendation is when you ask for their hibiscus water ask for an extra glass of regular water because they prepare a huge water jug with tons of sugar, wish they could do something with this. During the weekends you can try some special things in the menu like menudo or pozole which are very tasty stews of goat or belly. Hope you give a try soon!

Location

Welcome to Carniceria Guanajuato, a hidden gem located in Indianapolis, IN. This unique establishment offers a combination of a grocery store and a restaurant, providing customers with an authentic Mexican experience. The restaurant boasts a spacious and beautiful ambiance, making it a perfect spot for a casual lunch or dinner.

Customers rave about the tantalizing tacos at Carniceria Guanajuato, known for being both inexpensive and authentic. The Al pastor tacos stand out for their savory and juicy flavors, while the fish tacos offer a unique twist, despite being a bit dry. The menu, available in both Spanish and English, offers a variety of traditional Mexican dishes that are sure to satisfy your cravings.

One of the standout features of Carniceria Guanajuato is its Surf and Turf option, perfect for those looking to indulge in a hearty meal. The Carnitas enchiladas and Chorizo tacos are highly recommended for their delicious flavors, though the authentic preparation may not be for everyone. The grocery side of the establishment provides a diverse selection of fresh produce and meats, including the popular queso oaxaca.

Overall, Carniceria Guanajuato promises a memorable dining experience with its generous portions, affordable prices, and friendly service. Whether you're craving traditional Mexican fare or looking to explore new flavors, this restaurant is a must-try in Indianapolis.